Can I compare an FOB price with a CIF price?
Not directly. The CIF price includes freight and insurance. Compare the included and excluded costs first, then compare the numbers on the same term.
Two frozen chicken quotations are comparable only when they describe the same SKU, partner plant, packing, certificate scope and trade term.
A quotation that names only “frozen chicken” is a category, not an offer. The same supplier can quote whole chicken, breast, legs, wings or drumettes, each with a different weight band and packing. Ask for the SKU and repeat it on every revised quotation.
If the supplier uses a different SKU system, ask for a one-line description that matches your reference. Keep both codes on the comparison sheet so the commercial and production teams read the same product.
A category name also hides the cut. “Frozen chicken” can mean a whole bird, a breast, a leg or a wing. Ask for the cut, the weight band and the packing in the same line. If one of those fields is missing, the quotation is a starting point, not a comparable offer.
FOB, CFR, CIF and EXW prices are not comparable until the port, the Incoterm version and the included costs are the same. A CIF price includes freight and insurance; an FOB price does not. The difference is not a discount or a premium until the scope is the same.
Write the trade term next to every price. When a supplier revises a quote, check whether the term changed as well as the number. A lower price on a different term may not be a lower landed cost.
The partner plant is part of the offer. The same SKU can be produced at two sites with different certificate coverage and different packing lines. Ask which plant is assigned to the order and write it on the quotation.
Do not accept a plant name only in a covering email. The quotation or the specification sheet should name the plant. If the plant changes after the order, treat it as a written change with a specification and certificate impact.
Packing changes the load plan. A 2 kg × 6 bags carton and a 5 kg × 2 bags carton can hold the same product but plan differently. Ask for the carton net weight, bag count, film type and carton colour.
If the quotation does not state the packing, the price is incomplete. A low price with a different carton count may not be a lower cost per kilogram once the load is planned.
Ask what is included in the price: product, packing, inland transport to the port, export documents, freight, insurance and destination charges. The answer should be a list of included and excluded items, not a promise that “everything is included”.
The website does not publish freight or tax rates. Those depend on the port pair, the date and the carrier. A quotation should state the basis and the validity date so the buyer knows when to recheck.
A list is more useful than a single number. If two suppliers both say “CIF”, ask each one to mark which destination charges are included. The comparison becomes a checklist of cost lines rather than a debate about which number is lower.
A certificate applies to the holder, scope and annex printed on the document. Ask for the certificate that matches the partner plant and the exact item. A broad category name is not the same as a named cut.
The current chicken file covers HACCP at the Weifang and Fuxin partner plants, FSSC 22000 at Weifang, Halal at Weifang with eight listed chicken items and at Fuxin with thirty-four listed chicken items, and a food production licence at Weifang. Match the annex item before treating a SKU as covered.
A practical sheet has one row per offer and one column per field: SKU, description, partner plant, weight band, packing, cut statement, moisture wording, certificate holder, certificate scope, annex reference, validity date, trade term, port, price, price validity and document list.
Any blank cell is a question, not a zero. When a supplier revises a quote, update the cell and keep the old version. The history matters when a shipment is checked months later.
Add a revision column with the date and the reason for the change. A price change caused by a different plant is not the same as a price change caused by a different packing line. The reason tells the buyer which field to recheck before the order is placed.
A good RFQ gives the supplier enough to answer on the same basis: SKU or product description, quantity and unit, destination country and port, weight band, packing requirement, trade term, expected purchase window and any certificate or label requirement.
The more precise the RFQ, the easier it is to compare replies. The goal is not to send a longer email; it is to remove the fields that would otherwise be filled by assumptions.
Not directly. The CIF price includes freight and insurance. Compare the included and excluded costs first, then compare the numbers on the same term.
Ask for a price basis and a quantity unit that the supplier can confirm. The website does not publish a fixed container load, and the load depends on the SKU and packing.
Treat the plant as an open field. A quotation without a plant cannot be matched to a certificate or a packing line.
Tell us the SKU, quantity and destination port, and we will reply on the same trade term.
Request a quotation